How to Fish Game 8 Player Lobby Setup

Count the eight slots correctly

Up to eight players means eight total participants, including the person hosting. Plan for one host and as many as seven guests, not a host plus eight guests. Choose a backup host before starting so one comparison can be run without reorganizing the entire group.

Ask every player to restart Steam, complete How to Fish updates, and state the version they see. A launchable game is not proof that all eight installations match. Anyone with a suspected install issue should run Verify integrity before invitations begin.

Choose public or invite-only behavior

Patch 1.0.5 added private invite-only lobby and session settings. The host should decide the privacy mode before creating the session and tell the group what to expect. In an invite-only session, send each player a fresh invitation from the current lobby rather than asking them to find it as though it were public.

If the wrong setting was chosen, close the lobby normally and create a new one. Reusing an invitation from a closed or earlier session can introduce needless ambiguity. Keep one host, one privacy choice, and one new lobby identifier for the controlled attempt.

Add players one at a time

This staged method does not reduce the supported maximum; it makes troubleshooting possible. If the seventh join fails, for example, you can test that same person in a two-player lobby and distinguish a player-specific problem from a repeatable count boundary.

1. Have the host enter a fresh lobby alone and confirm the session is responsive.
2. Invite the first guest and wait for a fully usable view before sending another invitation.
3. Add guests individually, writing down the join order and current total.
4. After each join, confirm that existing players still respond normally.
5. At the first black screen, timeout, or disconnect, stop adding people and capture what host and guest see.
6. If all eight arrive, allow the session to settle before everyone begins different actions.

Protect progress before the event

Each player should save normally, exit How to Fish, and copy their own complete folder from C:\Users\<name>\AppData\LocalLow\Dazed Games\How to Fish\Saves to a dated backup. Keep copies separate by player and computer. Do not exchange or merge folders to make lobby access work.

Patch 1.0.6 says normal writes happen through manual Save, Main Menu, Quit, and an autosave about once per minute; a crash no longer triggers an immediate save. Encourage deliberate saves before the large-lobby test and normal exits afterward. A backup is protection, not a networking fix.

Respond to a failed join methodically

1. Record the exact player count, join order, host, privacy setting, and game version.
2. If the screen is black, note whether audio or menus respond and whether the host sees the guest.
3. Close the failed session normally and restart Steam on the host and affected player.
4. Verify files on the affected PC, then test that player alone with the same host.
5. Swap to the backup host for one comparison if the two-person test still fails.
6. Only after the comparison works should the group rebuild the larger lobby.

Use official connection evidence

If Steam Relay debug turns red, record the timing and consult the developer's official Discord common-bugs guidance. The red state is evidence to include, not a diagnosis by itself. The official sources used here do not establish a list of router ports for How to Fish.

Do not permanently disable firewall protection, forward guessed ports, or install an unknown lobby utility. For a reproducible failure, report the version matrix, host, privacy mode, exact count, affected join order, Relay state, and results of host swapping and verification through the official community route.

Explain the four-versus-eight discrepancy

Players quoting four are usually reading the older Steam store description. Players quoting eight are relying on the later 1.0.4 patch note. These statements reflect different points in the game's update history; the patch note explicitly changes the lobby capacity to up to eight.

Keep this timing in mind when reading community answers. An older answer may have been accurate before 1.0.4, and an undated screenshot may not show the 1.0.5 privacy settings. For current troubleshooting, always attach the actual build version rather than relying on the age of the discussion alone.

Questions players ask

Continue with the right tool